EP004 - Challenge of the Samurai

EP004 - Challenge of the Samurai

Challenge of the Samurai Boy!

Original Airdates: April 22, 1997 (JP), September 11, 1998 (EN)

Written by: Hideki Sonoda

Synopsis:

Still travelling through the Viridian Forest, Satoshi attempts to catch a Weedle, but it escapes when a strange trainer who calls himself “Samurai” challenges him to a battle.  In the middle of a Metapod vs. Metapod standstill, a swarm of Beedrill attacks, interrupting the fight.  Satoshi’s Metapod gets kidnapped by a Beedrill and ends up in their nest.

Satoshi and Kasumi spend the night in Samurai’s cabin to stay safe, but Satoshi feels bad for abandoning Metapod.  The next day he rescues Metapod by infiltrating the nest and it evolves into Butterfree.  Butterfree uses Sleep Powder to quell the swarm, allowing our heroes to escape.  Samurai considers the prior battle a victory in Satoshi’s favor and leads them out of the forest.

Who’s That Pokémon?

It's Metapod, because Ash abandons his Metapod (and battles another Metapod).

New Character and Pokémon Breakdown

Ash's Butterfree

Part 2 of the Ash's Butterfree saga focuses on its Metapod stage.  Being an immobile pupa, Metapod cannot battle well or defend itself in trouble.  As a result, Ash is forced to leave it behind, giving the creature severe abandonment issues.  Just because it hasn't reached its full potential, it feels inferior.  Fortunately, it is able to induce an early evolution when he sees its trainer in trouble, much as Pikachu finally came through for Ash against the Spearow.  As a Butterfree, he can finally prove that he's a capable fighter...yet he all but disappears after this episode.

Samurai

We meet our first “Character of the Day,” which is a character that only appears in one episode and never comes back, despite promises to return.  Samurai is a memorable COD because he introduces the concept of legal Pokémon battles (not just random Team Rocket attacks).  He is based on the Bug Catchers of Viridian Forest who are the first Trainers in the games (besides the rival).  Usually the problem with COD’s is that they are only there to showcase the Pokémon of the Day making those episodes seem rather meaningless.  Samurai does introduce a new Pokémon (Pinsir) but his Pokémon are not the focus of the episode.  The main plot revolves around the wild Beedrill and Satoshi’s Metapod.  Samurai is a source of chaos unto himself and he is there to put Satoshi’s skills to the test.

Samurai's Pinsir and Metapod

Somehow, the Samurai managed to get a Pinsir this early in his journey (maybe its his starter).  But despite its vast strength, it is still able to be taken out by a Metapod.  Kind of lame (but cool, at the same time).  The Metapod vs. Metapod Hardening battle, however, is a funny concept, but useless to the point of being a little contrived.  What were the Trainers expecting to happen?  Satoshi’s Metapod at least knew Tackle, so the battle could have gone somewhere.  But there was no point in prolonging the standstill.

Weedle, Kakuna, and Beedrill

Ash nearly catches a Weedle, but Samurai disrupts his concentration and the Weedle manages to escape (and possible alert the nest of Beedrill).  We later see more Weedle at the Beedrill nest, eating Team Rocket's...cardboard vehicle?  The Kakuna and Beedrill, like the Spearow, are just forces of nature, bent on destroying anything that disrupts their rest and privacy.  With all of these dangerous Beedrill around, its a wonder anyone makes it through Viridian Forest alive.

Bulbasaur, Charmander, and Squritle

In static flashback shots, we see that starter Pokémon that Oak handed out too the other three trainers from Pallet, each one battling with the Samurai.  At this moment, though, we still don't know which one Gary started with, so don't spoil it please!

Japanese vs. American Versions:

- Most jokes are rewritten to moderate effect, but the oddest one is Ash dressed as a cow saying “Cowterpie?” because in the original “Mushi (bug)” is similar to “Ushi (cow).”

Overall Review: A-

            

The humor from the previous episode continues here, as Satoshi and co. find themselves in sillier situations (like the intense little boy who demands to fight with honor).  Team Rocket is used nicely in that they are purely comic relief and they do not overstay their welcome.  By insisting on completing their motto which results in waking the Beedrill, they present a funny variation on the now recurring motto gag.

Once the drama kicks in, things begin to get a little uneven.  The abandoning Metapod plot comes a little out of nowhere.  Satoshi is so upset with himself, but, he really had no other choice.  He would have gotten himself killed had he tried to save Metapod earlier.  He acts as if he was a horrible person who made many mistakes, but it really was just the one.  And, despite what Samurai would have him believe, Weedle getting away was totally Samurai’s fault.  Satoshi needn't be so hard on himself.  But he grows.

My favorite aspect of this episode is the attention to detail given to the various Pokémon, treating them like actual animals rather than completely fantastical creatures.  The sights of Kakuna and Metapod evolving are quite stunning as they actually break out of their hard shells as opposed to glowing and transforming.  I wish later episodes had kept this dynamic.

This is a very well-balanced episode and it shows a level of quality and attention to detail of both the characters and the world around them.  It's a solid and funny episode that moves along quickly and develops Satoshi’s character in a positive way.